comparisons

Gemini 4 Carbon API vs Claude Opus 5.5 API vs GPT-6 Astra API: Benchmarks, Price per Request, One Key

Poyo.ai Team
10 min read
Share:

Gemini 4 Carbon API vs Claude Opus 5.5 API vs GPT-6 Astra API comparison

The Gemini 4 Carbon API (gemini-4-carbon, model page) costs a fifth of GPT-6 Astra's per-token price and half of Claude Opus 5.5's, and Google's launch table puts it first on 11 of 13 benchmarks against both. This post lays that table next to the price of an identical request on each API, shows where Claude Opus 5.5 and GPT-6 Astra still lead, and calls all three with one PoYo key.

If you're only deciding between Google's two models, read Gemini 4 Carbon API vs Gemini 4 Argon API instead.

API facts side by side

Gemini 4 CarbonClaude Opus 5.5GPT-6 Astra
PoYo model IDgemini-4-carbonclaude-opus-5-5gpt-6-astra
OpenAI-compatible Chat Completions✓✓✓
Native format on PoYoGemini Native (/v1beta/models/{model}:generateContent)Anthropic Messages (/v1/messages)Responses (/v1/responses)
Context window1M tokens1M tokens1,050,000 tokens
Max output64K tokens128K tokens128K tokens
Streamingstream: true / :streamGenerateContentstream: truestream: true

Every model on this list supports Chat Completions on PoYo, so one OpenAI SDK client can call all three. The native formats add each vendor's own features. PoYo documents tool use and cache_control in Anthropic Messages, and tools such as web search in Responses. Its Gemini Native docs cover contents, generationConfig, and inline multimodal data.

Price per 1M tokens: PoYo and official

PoYo prices come from the model pages (1 credit = $0.005). Official prices were read on November 16, 2026 from Google's Carbon launch posts, Anthropic's pricing page, and OpenAI's pricing page.

Meter (per 1M tokens)Gemini 4 CarbonClaude Opus 5.5GPT-6 Astra
PoYo input$1.60 (320 credits)$3.20 (640 credits)$8.00 (1,600 credits)
PoYo output$8.00 (1,600 credits)$16.00 (3,200 credits)$40.00 (8,000 credits)
PoYo cache read$0.08$0.16$0.80
PoYo cache write—$4.00 (5m) / $6.40 (1h)$10.00
Official input$2.00 (introductory)$4.00$10.00 (≤272K input)
Official output$10.00 (introductory)$20.00$50.00 (≤272K input)
Official cache read$0.10 (95% off input)$0.20$1.00

Three notes on the official columns:

  • Google: $2 / $10 is Carbon's introductory price. Google's availability post says the introductory period ends on November 30, 2026, and $4 input and $20 output per 1M tokens apply from December 1. Output includes thinking tokens.
  • Anthropic: the full 1M-token context window is billed at the standard rate, so a 900K-token request costs the same per token as a 9K-token request.
  • OpenAI: requests over 272K input tokens are billed at $20 input, $2 cached input, and $75 output per 1M on the standard tier. PoYo's model page lists one Astra tier. Check it before you send Astra very long prompts.

Carbon's full breakdown is in the Gemini 4 Carbon API pricing post.

Cost per request with identical token counts

The same request shape on all three, billed at PoYo rates and at official standard rates. Real token counts differ by model: each vendor tokenizes differently, and Google says Carbon spends more tokens than Argon to reason and verify. Treat these as per-token comparisons, then measure your own traffic.

Request A: 100K input + 10K output (a large code review)

Gemini 4 CarbonClaude Opus 5.5GPT-6 Astra
PoYo0.1 × 1.60 + 0.01 × 8 = $0.24 (48 credits)0.1 × 3.20 + 0.01 × 16 = $0.48 (96 credits)0.1 × 8 + 0.01 × 40 = $1.20 (240 credits)
Official$0.30$0.60$1.50

Request B: 500K input + 30K output (a repository loaded into context)

Gemini 4 CarbonClaude Opus 5.5GPT-6 Astra
PoYo0.5 × 1.60 + 0.03 × 8 = $1.04 (208 credits)0.5 × 3.20 + 0.03 × 16 = $2.08 (416 credits)0.5 × 8 + 0.03 × 40 = $5.20 (1,040 credits)
Official$1.30$2.60$12.25 (long-context band: 0.5 × 20 + 0.03 × 75)

At equal token counts, Opus 5.5 costs exactly 2× Carbon and Astra 5× Carbon on PoYo. To break even with Carbon on a given task, Opus 5.5 would need to finish it in half the tokens, and Astra in a fifth.

Benchmarks: Google's table, not a neutral one

These scores come from Google's benchmark table in its Gemini 4 Carbon launch post. It's the vendor's own comparison, run on the harnesses Google chose. Use it to decide what to test, not as a final ranking.

BenchmarkGemini 4 CarbonClaude Opus 5.5GPT-6 AstraLeader
AA Intelligence Index v5.0595857Carbon
Vals Index v2.270.4%70.2%65.0%Carbon
Terminal-Bench 4.0 (AA)65.2%59.6%59.1%Carbon
SWE-sweep9.6%3.6%9.5%Carbon
FrontierSWE 261.2%62.3%65.5%GPT-6 Astra
Agents' Last Exam v1.177.4%71.6%73.1%Carbon
OSWorld-2.1 (offline subset)81.5%87.2%80.9%Claude Opus 5.5
AutomationBench (Zapier)53.9%42.5%41.4%Carbon
GraphWalks 256K–1M (BFS F1)96.2%66.8%71.8%Carbon
RiemannBench80.0%69.6%72.0%Carbon
CWE-bench71.0%67.0%68.0%Carbon
ExploitGym54.8%34.5%42.4%Carbon
SEC-bench Pro88.2%—85.4%Carbon

"—" means Google published no score. Google's cybersecurity results (CWE-bench, ExploitGym, SEC-bench Pro) reflect access through its Fairwind Program. Its availability post says Carbon for cyber is offered only through that program.

Some leads are within noise. Carbon's margin is 0.2 points on Vals Index and 0.1 on SWE-sweep. Harnesses also differ between tables. Google's earlier Argon table, quoted in our Argon guide, shows Opus 5.5 at 66.4% on Terminal-Bench 4.0, while this table shows 59.6% on the Artificial Analysis harness.

Where each API leads, as routing advice

Send toRequest typesEvidence in Google's table
gemini-4-carbonQuestions over 256K–1M tokens of context, terminal agents, business automation, exploit validation, mathGraphWalks 96.2% vs 66.8–71.8%; Terminal-Bench 65.2%; AutomationBench 53.9% vs 41–43%; ExploitGym 54.8%
gpt-6-astraSoftware-engineering tasks shaped like FrontierSWE, when you can afford 5× Carbon's token priceFrontierSWE 2 65.5% vs 61.2%
claude-opus-5-5Computer-use agents (OSWorld-style desktop tasks)OSWorld-2.1 87.2% vs 81.5%

On price alone, Carbon is the default and the other two are targeted exceptions. Carbon's 64K output cap is the main constraint. Opus 5.5 and GPT-6 Astra both list 128K max output, so a single response longer than 64K has to go elsewhere. Our Carbon vs Argon post covers routing those requests to Argon.

Call all three with one PoYo key

Chat Completions takes the same body for every model, so the OpenAI SDK is enough to run all three on the same prompt:

import os
from openai import OpenAI

client = OpenAI(api_key=os.environ["POYO_API_KEY"], base_url="https://api.poyo.ai/v1")

# PoYo USD per 1M tokens (input, output), from the model pages on 2026-11-16
PRICES = {
    "gemini-4-carbon": (1.60, 8.00),
    "claude-opus-5-5": (3.20, 16.00),
    "gpt-6-astra": (8.00, 40.00),
}

messages = [{"role": "user", "content": "Review this diff for race conditions:\n<diff here>"}]

for model_id, (price_in, price_out) in PRICES.items():
    resp = client.chat.completions.create(model=model_id, messages=messages, max_tokens=8000)
    u = resp.usage
    cost = u.prompt_tokens / 1e6 * price_in + u.completion_tokens / 1e6 * price_out
    print(model_id, u.prompt_tokens, u.completion_tokens, f"${cost:.4f}")
    print(resp.choices[0].message.content[:500])

The printed prompt_tokens and completion_tokens give you the real per-request comparison that the tables above only approximate. The estimate counts all input as uncached, so it's an upper bound.

When you need vendor-specific features, use each model's native format with the same key.

Gemini Native for Carbon (the model goes in the path):

curl https://api.poyo.ai/v1beta/models/gemini-4-carbon:generateContent \
  -H "Authorization: Bearer $POYO_API_KEY" \
  -H "Content-Type: application/json" \
  -d '{
    "contents": [{"role": "user", "parts": [{"text": "Review this diff for race conditions: ..."}]}],
    "generationConfig": {"maxOutputTokens": 8000}
  }'

Anthropic Messages for Opus 5.5 (max_tokens is required; x-api-key also works, so the Anthropic SDK only needs its base URL set to https://api.poyo.ai):

curl https://api.poyo.ai/v1/messages \
  -H "Authorization: Bearer $POYO_API_KEY" \
  -H "Content-Type: application/json" \
  -d '{
    "model": "claude-opus-5-5",
    "max_tokens": 8000,
    "messages": [{"role": "user", "content": "Review this diff for race conditions: ..."}]
  }'

Responses for GPT-6 Astra:

curl https://api.poyo.ai/v1/responses \
  -H "Authorization: Bearer $POYO_API_KEY" \
  -H "Content-Type: application/json" \
  -d '{
    "model": "gpt-6-astra",
    "input": "Review this diff for race conditions: ...",
    "max_output_tokens": 8000
  }'

Errors follow each format's own shape. 400 covers invalid fields, or a model sent to a format it doesn't support (the message lists the supported URIs). 401 means a bad key and 404 an unknown model ID. For Carbon's first request in detail, see the Gemini 4 Carbon API guide.

Frequently asked questions

Is the Gemini 4 Carbon API cheaper than the Claude Opus 5.5 API?

Yes, per token. On PoYo, Carbon costs $1.60 input and $8.00 output per 1M tokens, against $3.20 and $16.00 for Opus 5.5. Officially it's $2 / $10 (introductory) against $4 / $20.

How much does the GPT-6 Astra API cost compared with Gemini 4 Carbon?

On PoYo, GPT-6 Astra costs $8.00 input and $40.00 output per 1M tokens, 5× Carbon. OpenAI's standard price is $10 / $50 up to 272K input tokens and $20 / $75 above that.

Which API is best for coding: Gemini 4 Carbon, Claude Opus 5.5, or GPT-6 Astra?

In Google's table, Carbon leads Terminal-Bench 4.0 (AA) at 65.2% and SWE-sweep at 9.6%, while GPT-6 Astra leads FrontierSWE 2 at 65.5%. These are Google's numbers. Run your own repository tasks through all three with the script above before you commit.

Can I call Gemini 4 Carbon, Claude Opus 5.5, and GPT-6 Astra with the OpenAI SDK?

Yes. Set base_url to https://api.poyo.ai/v1, use your PoYo API key, and change only model. All three support PoYo's Chat Completions endpoint.

Which API is best for computer-use agents?

Claude Opus 5.5 leads OSWorld-2.1 (offline subset) in Google's table at 87.2%, ahead of Carbon at 81.5% and GPT-6 Astra at 80.9%.

Does the Gemini 4 Carbon API support a 1M-token context?

Yes. Carbon accepts up to 1M input tokens and returns up to 64K output tokens. In Google's table it scores 96.2% on GraphWalks at 256K–1M tokens, against 66.8% for Opus 5.5 and 71.8% for GPT-6 Astra.

Share: